Cleveland Browns - Tim Couch: 1st round, 1st overall (1999)

Expected to be the face of the franchise, Couch instead threw three more interceptions (67) than touchdowns (64) before Cleveland moved on from him after just five seasons. Johnny Manziel (22nd overall in 2014) and Brandon Weeden (22nd overall in 2012) are two recent first round picks by the Browns that also didn’t come close to panning out.