Cincinnati Bengals - Akili Smith: 1st round, 3rd overall (1999)

A 3-14 record as starting quarterback with just five career touchdown passes? It’s safe to say Smith was a major disappointment in Cincinnati. He’s far from the only bust at quarterback for the Bengals though as David Klingler (sixth overall in 1992), Jack Thompson (third overall in 1979), and Greg Cook (fifth overall in 1969) all merit mention.