Denver Broncos - Paxton Lynch: 1st round, 26th overall (2016)

Lynch gets the slight edge over Tommy Maddox (25th overall in 1992) who at least recovered to be an adequate starter for the Steelers, and Tim Tebow (25th overall in 2010) who at least won a playoff game for Denver. Despite the Broncos having subpar quarterback play in recent years, Lynch was only called on to start four times in 2016-17 before Denver cut him prior to the 2018 season.