Jason Kipnis, Indians

Kipnis has now had two straight subpar seasons for Cleveland. The two-time All-Star did hit 18 homers and 28 doubles but batted just .230 with a .704 OPS. Turning 32 on April 3, it doesn't seem all that likely he will return to the player who four times had a WAR of at least 3.9. He is steady in the field with just 16 errors over the last two years.